I read a lot of blog posts every day. Once in a great while, a post hits me so deeply that it stays with me and rattles around in my mind long after I walk away from the computer. Paula O’s,Just What Are We Expecting? is one of those posts.
Where I read the recent story of a diplomat and his wife abandoning their 7 year old daughter and reacted by saying “That is so awful. How could anyone do such a thing?” Paula stepped back and said, “What is the mindset that leads to such a thing?” And in so doing she showed me that to some degree every adoptive parent places unfair expectations on their child — I know I did. Or rather, to be honest, I do.
Logically, I knew that bonding is a process, not an instant magical moment of falling in love at first sight. But still it bothered me to realize that my new son wanted nothing to do with me that very first day – and that even after a few weeks together I felt no more “attached” to him than I would to any random child in my care. And while rationally it seems obvious that the child you adopt will have habits and mannerisms already formed and established when they come into your life, it still took me by surprise when Zeeb did so many things that felt unfamiliar and even annoying to me. And don’t even get me started on what it was like parenting a three year old boy who spoke a completely different language – for months. I did the reading, I knew that a three year old would be speaking some Vietnamese. But I didn’t anticipate how much he was speaking (despite the progress reports that told me he spoke in sentences). And everyone told me that it was simply “amazing” how quickly a child switches to a new language – within days or weeks they said. Not my Zeeb. He did pick up some English early on, but he kept Vietnamese as his primary language for a good long time. And it made me mad. Oh in my mind I knew it made sense and I was even a little proud of my smart boy maintaining his Vietnamese without anyone around to converse with. But in my heart it drove me nuts and hurt my feelings too. And logically I know that there is nothing magical about the 1 year mark. But if I’m honest I have to admit I expected that by a year Zeeb would be fully bonded to us and adjusted to life here. More than that – I expected him to “fit in.” I expected him to put aside his first three years of life – all that shaped him and formed his personality – and become someone new. Lately I’ve realized I even expected more than that – more than putting aside all the nurturing influences of his first three years. I expected him to put aside his very nature to become the son of my dreams. The reality is, Zeeb’s temperment is different than mine. Which really isn’t an earth-shattering realization, but it does require me to adjust my expectations.
And there’s the parental rub – we are constantly needing to adjust our expectations. Not just with adopted children – certainly K~ and A~ do not always act the way I hope or expect them to. But there’s another layer with adoption – the months or years of built up hopes and dreams on the part of the parents, and the inherent nature of the child combined with months or years of life experiences that they bring with them into their new family.
Somehow I think I’m making “adjusting expectations” sound like a bad thing. But let’s face it, relationships are all about adjusting expectations. And love is all about accepting someone for who they are, not who we wish they were.
While all of this was percolating in my mind, a friend sent me a link to this article in Newsweek. Titled, “When Adoption Goes Wrong” it is a heartbreaking account of parental abuse and situations where children have severe attachment or behavioral issues that the parents were altogether unprepared for. In other words, it’s a look at extreme cases of unmet expectations. I appreciated that the article made one thing very clear:
Why do some adoptions go so wrong? Clearly, it’s not the kids’ fault.
Also, the reporter points out that most adoption agencies do a very poor job of preparing adoptive parents for the possibility that their child may have underlying issues.
“Very few agencies are training parents to deal with brain damage, sensory deprivation, aggression,” Purvis says. “A lot of these parents are smitten with the hope that they’ll make a difference in a child’s life, but they need very practical tools. I consider myself very pro-adoption. But I’m also very pro informed adoption. “
I agree with the points in the article, but I would take it even farther and say that agencies need to do a better job of setting expectations in general. Even a very “healthy” child comes to adoption as their own person with their own traits and temperment and mannerisms. But maybe it will take more than classes or recommended readings. Maybe we need to appeal to the emotions more than the mind.
I remember when I gave birth to my first child, I put all these expectations on myself – and on her. I expected to lose the pregnancy weight immediately and to intuitively know how to parent my daughter. And I expected her to eat and sleep on a schedule. Logically, not very realistic expectations. But I formed them from hearing stories about other women who quickly went back into their size 5 jeans and had their babies sleeping through the night in a matter of weeks. I don’t remember anyone saying to me “You’ll be tired and overwhelmed and the baby will defy all the great advice you read in parenting books.” I wish they had. (Mind you, my daughter was born before the “Girlfriend’s Guide” books, so maybe pregnant moms hear that now?) I think we as humans, or as a society or whatever, have a really bad habit of putting unrealistic expectations on others and on ourselves. We should knock that off. For starters, we could try being a little more honest with each other. We are imperfect people, and there is encouragement in knowing that others are imperfect too.
So I guess that’s what this post is about – putting myself out there and saying, “I’m imperfect. I had unrealistic expectations of my child. Adoption is not all sunshine and roses. Sometimes it’s hard.” But while I’m being honest I have to also say, “I wouldn’t trade my son for anything. He is not who I expected him to be, but he is exactly who he is supposed to be. Being his mom is not always easy, but it’s always a blessing.”




This is so well said and I completely identify with all of it. But I would go further and say that parents need to be told that not only is attachment for both parties not usually immediate, but that sometimes one can completely dislike the newly adopted child. I felt I was prepared in some degree for what was coming…that I may not instantly love my child, or him me, and that there would be grieving and maybe temper tantrums…I was completely unprepared for the degree in which we all experienced these emotions. I was shocked by his degree of grieving and his open dislike of us and I was just as shocked by my own reaction to his open dislike. I had never heard anyone else’s story that matched mine and I just knew I had ruined many people’s lives by adopting this child. Since our experience, I have heard many stories that are so similar to our own that it normalizes, in a way, what we all endured. Just knowing that others have gone through the same thing and have come out on the other side gives one hope to go on. I am happy to say that we have certainly come out on the side…and happily so. I wouldn’t change my son for the world; I love who he is. I heartily support the idea of “pro informed adoption”. Those of us who have had not so rosy transitions need to share our stories, not to scare people away, but by giving them information to make their own transitions easier. Or if not easier at least more hopeful.
Oh, that story makes my blood boil. We aren’t buying cabbage patch kids off the shelf.
This is a great post, Christina.
I am not perfect- so I am not trying to make myself seem this way with this story
; my situation was probably a bit different than yours when we first adopted – DH and I were 26, had no biological children and adoption was our first choice to build our family when we adopted G. Pre-adoption we talked about what we considered one of the biggest gifts of adoption – freeing ourselves of some of those preconceived notions/expectations. When someone births a child, you almost immediately here “oh, he does this like mommy”, “makes that face like Daddy” – my own sister had her newborn son pegged as a future accountant (like Dad) within weeks of his birth because he was so obviously fascinated by numbers
With G., we realized we were getting a gift – the gift of a person we did not know. We didn’t expect him to be anything like either of us – we just felt like we were watching this gift unfold every day and we just enjoyed letting him take the lead and show us who he was. Very exciting! And liberating as a family, I think.
G., it turns out, is this totally analytical, math-y young fellow. I can not relate to that AT ALL – but I sure do appreciate, respect admire his very different way of looking at the world.
I admit it was much harder with S – a toddler at adoption who had a very strong, set personality. In that way, I relate to the difficulties in getting to know/bond. He felt like a more developed person than G. was. He had more difficult life-experiences under his belt already, and he was suspicious of us. It did take some time, and I sure had my doubts that all would be well – but again watching my stubborn, anxious little gift unfold was pretty awesome. It was harder and took longer, but awesome all the same.
Turns out S. is the world’s greatest 6 year old physical comedian AND extremely determined. I can’t relate to every way he looks at the world, but I do love who he is.
You’ve written some very good stuff here. Well Done! And Merry Christmas.
Christina-
I knew there was a reason that I loved your blog-
Ha-
Seriously- you put it all out there so perfectly. Thank you- I am so grateful for bloggers like you and Paula O.
This topic is so complex and has so many layers. I used to think that loving Khai should feel exactly the same, and that being an adoptive parent should be the same- but it isn’t there is so much more to it, but it all those complexities aren’t bad. All those complexities can bring understanding and change in us, if we let them.
This is where I really struggle is with all the people who view hard and different as inherently bad. Hard is not bad, especially when it makes us more like Jesus.
Christina said, ““I’m imperfect. I had unrealistic expectations of my child. Adoption is not all sunshine and roses. Sometimes it’s hard.” But while I’m being honest I have to also say, “I wouldn’t trade my son for anything. He is not who I expected him to be, but he is exactly who he is supposed to be. Being his mom is not always easy, but it’s always a blessing.””
AMEN. Thank you for such lovely post. I couldn’t have said it better myself.
Gretchen
I live in Holland and this story has outraged the Dutch people. There is a push for this consulate to resign and I’ll be polite and not repeat what’s being said about his wife….
You have touched on so many points here and I read the whole thing nodding in agreement. But this sentence in particular stood out to me…
“And while rationally it seems obvious that the child you adopt will have habits and mannerisms already formed and established when they come into your life, it still took me by surprise when Zeeb did so many things that felt unfamiliar and even annoying to me. ”
This has been our biggest obstacle. And now even 9 months later I still find myself deciphering between personality traits and lingering orphanage habits. This part was SO much more difficult than I could have ever imagined. During the first few months I had moments when I wondered if I was an awful mother, and I’ll be honest the memory of those first few months makes me question whether or not I would adopt a preschool aged child again. And Sera adjusted easily, so the thought of possibly going through these things with a child who has attachment issues is downright frightening to me.
As always, I appreciate your honesty. Reading about your experiences has really helped me cope with all the ups and downs of our adoption of Sera. So, THANK YOU!
I notice that I am more critical of Pineapple’s misbehaviors until I remember my bio kids doing the same thing. Sometimes I start thinking she is going to grow up with a lot of problems. Like when she is biting and hitting everyone or tearing up my photographs or getting into my makeup or breaking the Christmas decorations, but then I remember that my boys did all of that kind of stuff at her age. When I realize that- it makes me feel like it’s O.K. she is going to be O.K. I am not totally messing up here. I think I can accept this behavior, but it is still harder for some reason. I realized that I expect better behavior from her than from my boys. I need to let go of that. I am not even sure why I feel that way.
Such good points!
I think the reason I’ve had such a relatively great time being a mom so far is due to 1) my disgustingly easy kid and 2) the lowest of low expectations going into it. I grew up hearing my mom talk about what a nightmare she had trying to breastfeed me, my friends had post-partum depression, etc. etc. So I was not assuming anything except the worst! (Knowing it would be totally worth it, of course!)
And I do want to tell you that while I still would like to adopt one day, I have changed from Rosy Cheeked Bright Eyed Hopeful Idealist Future Adopter to Gritting My Teeth Future Adopter, totally because of your blog alone. And I mean that in a completely good way! When we do get around to the adoption thing I will track you down (are you still going to Colorado?) and make you walk me through the entire process. You think I’m kidding BUT I’M NOT.
Maggie,
Thanks for the compliment (I think! ha ha) – I used to be that Rosy Cheeked … adopter but now I shake my head at that naïveté, so I guess it’s good I knocked that right out of you! LOL
Don’t know about Colorado… still want to move, but so far no great leads for hubby. Apparently there’s just WAY more good software type jobs out here than in Denver. sigh. (I love it here in the NW, I really do, but the rain is starting to get to me!) But wherever I am, I would be HAPPY to help you with the adoption process… hand holding, advice, just listening… whatever you need, I’m here!!
This is all pretty foreign to me. My biggest concern besides actually getting a visa so I could bring my child home, was that I could provide a happy sort of life for her, that I could help her pull herself together so she could feel good about the world.
I can’t imagine having expectations for another person let alone a baby, toddler or child. They are what they are, as a parent you hope to create a safe place for your child so all the best in them can bloom. You hope to encourage all God intended in this person.
Why would you insist your orchid be a rose? How could you look on an orchid and say how much you miss the scent and symmetry of a rose. It’s an orchid and there are other things about an orchid to get excited about.
My child came like a bare root or bulb. It needed a lot of tending before I could see what I really had. She has exceeded my wildest dreams in every way and she is like no one I have ever met.
Save expectations for yourself.
Thanks so much for sharing this…it’s coming at a particularly good time for us. I have to admit, I’m pretty scared right now about what we’ll be getting into with the little girl we have decided to adopt. Not that I’m second-guessing it, because I’m not. But because she’s so much older than our other children were. She will have developed so much more of her personality and have so many habits and traits hard-wired that it will be more difficult of an adjustment I believe.
We already know we’re going to have some bonding issues. She runs from one stranger to another wanting to be held…but honestly that doesn’t scare me too much. With a lot of hard work and supervision, I honestly believe we’ll be fine. It’s the unknown that is scary.
When we brought Punky home in 2002 I had some real issues in dealing with her. Part of it was her age, part of it was the fact that I had never mothered a girl before and part of it was her incredibly strong personality and the fact that I was going through post-adoption depression. I’m glad to say that five years later we are doing GREAT! Better than I could ever have imagined.
I need to remember that…and I need to remember not to put my expectations on the child – but to love and appreciate them for who they are.
You’re right…they are who they are supposed to be.
Thanks.